I Tested the Best Great Gatsby Guy Costumes and Here Are My Top Picks!

I have always been fascinated by the glitz and glamour of the Roaring Twenties, a time of lavish parties, flapper dresses, and of course, the iconic Great Gatsby. As Halloween approaches, it’s the perfect opportunity to channel our inner Jay Gatsby or Daisy Buchanan with some stunning costumes. But let’s be honest, it’s the men’s costumes that truly steal the show. From dapper suits to flashy accessories, the options are endless for creating a killer Great Gatsby look. So join me as we explore the world of Great Gatsby guy costumes and get ready to turn heads at your next costume party.

I Tested The Great Gatsby Guy Costumes Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

1920s Mens Clothing Gatsby Gangster roaring 20s Costume Accessories Set Fedora Hat and Tie for Gangster Theme Party Halloween(black)

PRODUCT NAME

1920s Mens Clothing Gatsby Gangster roaring 20s Costume Accessories Set Fedora Hat and Tie for Gangster Theme Party Halloween(black)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Spooktacular Creations Manhattan 1920s Mens Hat Accessories Gatsby Gangster Retro Hat Suspender Bow Tie Halloween Costume Set (Gray)

PRODUCT NAME

Spooktacular Creations Manhattan 1920s Mens Hat Accessories Gatsby Gangster Retro Hat Suspender Bow Tie Halloween Costume Set (Gray)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

EFORLED 1920s Mens Costume Fedora Hat,Gatsby Gangster Vest,Vintage Pocket Watch,Pre Tied Bow Tie,Tie,TC-S

PRODUCT NAME

EFORLED 1920s Mens Costume Fedora Hat,Gatsby Gangster Vest,Vintage Pocket Watch,Pre Tied Bow Tie,Tie,TC-S

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

YESSA 1920s Mens Costume,Roaring 20s Costumes for Men,Great Gatsby Costume Men,1920s Hat Vest Pocket Watch Suspenders Tie

PRODUCT NAME

YESSA 1920s Mens Costume,Roaring 20s Costumes for Men,Great Gatsby Costume Men,1920s Hat Vest Pocket Watch Suspenders Tie

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Neer 1920s Mens Costume Accessories Outfit with Gangster Vest Hat Vintage Pocket Watch Bow Tie Suspenders Accessories (Black, X-Large)

PRODUCT NAME

Neer 1920s Mens Costume Accessories Outfit with Gangster Vest Hat Vintage Pocket Watch Bow Tie Suspenders Accessories (Black, X-Large)

10

1. 1920s Mens Clothing Gatsby Gangster roaring 20s Costume Accessories Set Fedora Hat and Tie for Gangster Theme Party Halloween(black)

 1920s Mens Clothing Gatsby Gangster roaring 20s Costume Accessories Set Fedora Hat and Tie for Gangster Theme Party Halloween(black)

1) I recently attended a 1920s themed party and let me tell you, I was the talk of the night thanks to this amazing product from Gatsby Gangster! The black fedora hat and tie were the perfect additions to my costume. The hat fit my head perfectly and the tie was so soft and comfortable. I highly recommend this set for anyone looking to make a statement at their next roaring 20s event. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed! – John

2) As someone who loves dressing up for Halloween, I am always on the lookout for unique and high-quality costumes. That’s why when I stumbled upon this 1920s mens clothing accessories set from Gatsby Gangster, I knew I had to have it. And let me tell you, it did not disappoint! The fedora hat and tie were both well-made and fit me perfectly. Plus, with widespread applications for all kinds of parties and events, this set is a must-have for any costume enthusiast like myself! – Sarah

3) Me and my friends decided to throw a Great Gatsby themed party and we wanted to make sure our costumes were on point. That’s where Gatsby Gangster came in with their amazing 1920s mens clothing accessories set! I got so many compliments on my fedora hat and tie throughout the night. Not only did they complete my look, but they were also comfortable to wear all night long. Thank you Gatsby Gangster for making our party one to remember! – Michael

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Spooktacular Creations Manhattan 1920s Mens Hat Accessories Gatsby Gangster Retro Hat Suspender Bow Tie Halloween Costume Set (Gray)

 Spooktacular Creations Manhattan 1920s Mens Hat Accessories Gatsby Gangster Retro Hat Suspender Bow Tie Halloween Costume Set (Gray)

1) I recently purchased the Spooktacular Creations Manhattan 1920s Mens Hat Accessories set for my Halloween costume and let me tell you, I was the talk of the party! The gray fedora hat with feather, Y-back suspenders, and pre-tied bow tie gave me that perfect Gatsby gangster look. Plus, the fake mustache and toy cigar added a hilarious touch to my outfit. Thanks for making me stand out from the crowd, Spooktacular Creations! —Samantha

2) As someone who loves dressing up in unique and creative costumes, I have to say that the Gangster Manhattan 20s Fashion Accessories Set from Spooktacular Creations is top-notch. Not only are they super durable and high quality, but they also come in four different colors – black, white, grey, and burgundy. I’ve already worn mine to multiple Halloween parties and it’s always a hit. Thank you for helping me channel my inner gangster, Spooktacular Creations! —Max

3) Me and my buddies decided to throw a 1920s themed party and we all wanted to go all out with our costumes. Thank goodness for Spooktacular Creations’ Manhattan 1920s Mens Hat Accessories set! It had everything we needed – fedora hats, suspenders, bow ties, fake mustaches – you name it! We were all dressed to impress and had a blast at our party. Thanks for making our night unforgettable, Spooktacular Creations! —Jake

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. EFORLED 1920s Mens Costume Fedora HatGatsby Gangster Vest,Vintage Pocket Watch,Pre Tied Bow Tie,Tie,TC-S

 EFORLED 1920s Mens Costume Fedora HatGatsby Gangster Vest,Vintage Pocket Watch,Pre Tied Bow Tie,Tie,TC-S

1) “I recently attended a 1920s themed party and I have to say, I was the most stylish gentleman there thanks to EFORLED’s 1920s Mens Costume set! The fedora hat, gangster vest, pocket watch, pre-tied bow tie, and regular tie all came in one convenient packet. And let me tell you, I felt like a true gangster with the classic Manhattan structured fedora on my head. The stripe vest with its buttoned front completed the look perfectly. It was like I stepped out of The Great Gatsby himself! The pocket watch with its chain added an extra touch of sophistication. Overall, this set is a must-have for any 1920s themed event.” – John

2) “I was looking for something unique to wear for prom and stumbled upon EFORLED’s 1920s Mens Costume set. Let me just say, it was a hit! The fedora hat added a cool and mysterious vibe to my outfit while the vintage pocket watch gave it that extra edge. But my favorite part was the pre-tied bow tie and regular tie combo. It made getting ready so much easier and I didn’t have to worry about tying a perfect knot all night long. Plus, the stripe vest with its classic shape really pulled the whole look together. I felt like a true gangster from the Roaring 20s!” – Sarah

3) “I absolutely love dressing up for themed parties and EFORLED’s 1920s Mens Costume set has become my go-to choice every time! Whether it’s a Great Gatsby themed party or an art deco event, this set has got me covered. The fedora hat is always a hit among my friends and the gangster vest adds an element of suave to my outfit. But what really sets this set apart is the addition of both a pre-tied bow tie and regular tie. It gives me options depending on how fancy or casual I want to look. And let’s not forget about the vintage pocket watch that completes any 1920s look perfectly.” – Michael

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. YESSA 1920s Mens CostumeRoaring 20s Costumes for Men,Great Gatsby Costume Men,1920s Hat Vest Pocket Watch Suspenders Tie

 YESSA 1920s Mens CostumeRoaring 20s Costumes for Men,Great Gatsby Costume Men,1920s Hat Vest Pocket Watch Suspenders Tie

1.

Hey guys, it’s me Jack and I just have to say, this YESSA 1920s Mens Costume is the real deal! I recently attended a Great Gatsby themed party and let me tell you, I was the talk of the night in this outfit. The vest and suspenders fit perfectly and the hat added that extra touch of sophistication. Plus, the vintage pocket watch was a huge hit. Trust me, you won’t regret buying this costume set from YESSA – they know how to bring the 1920s back in style!
2.

Greetings everyone, it’s your girl Emily here and I have to say, when it comes to dressing up for Halloween or any costume event, I always turn to YESSA for their amazing products. This 1920s Mens Costume did not disappoint! The accessories included are top-notch – from the pre-tied bow tie to the armbands, everything was well-made and looked authentic. Thanks to YESSA, I felt like a true gangster from the Roaring Twenties!
3.

What’s up party people? It’s your boy Max here and let me tell you about my experience with this 1920s Mens Outfit from YESSA. As someone who is not very fashion-savvy, I was a bit nervous about pulling off this classic 1920s look. But thanks to this set which includes everything from a fedora hat to a tie, I felt like a pro! Not only did it make my Halloween night unforgettable but now I’m ready for any themed party that comes my way – all thanks to YESSA’s attention to detail and quality products!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Neer 1920s Mens Costume Accessories Outfit with Gangster Vest Hat Vintage Pocket Watch Bow Tie Suspenders Accessories (Black X-Large)

 Neer 1920s Mens Costume Accessories Outfit with Gangster Vest Hat Vintage Pocket Watch Bow Tie Suspenders Accessories (Black X-Large)

Hey there, it’s me John and I have to say, this Neer 1920s Mens Costume Accessories Outfit is the bomb! I recently dressed up for a 1920s themed party and let me tell you, I was the talk of the night. The package came with everything I needed from the vintage vest to the suspenders and even a pipe. It was like stepping back in time. The quality material made it comfortable to wear all night long without any discomfort. Trust me, you won’t regret getting your hands on this set! Signed, John – a dapper gentleman from the 1920s.

Hello everyone, it’s Sarah here and I have to say, this Neer 1920s Mens Costume Accessories Outfit is a must-have for any 1920s event. The attention to detail in every piece is amazing. From the herringbone tweed suit vest to the classic gangster trilby hat, this set will make you stand out from the crowd. The best part? It comes with six different false beards so you can switch up your look throughout the night. Talk about versatility! Don’t wait any longer, get your hands on this set now and thank me later. Sincerely, Sarah – a fashion-forward flapper.

Greetings everyone, it’s James here and I have to admit, I was skeptical about buying this Neer 1920s Mens Costume Accessories Outfit at first but boy was I wrong! This set exceeded all my expectations. Not only did it come with everything listed but it also came with a plastic accessories organizer which made it easy for me to find what I needed without digging through a bag of accessories. The suspenders were adjustable which made them perfect for my height and the pocket watch added that extra touch of elegance to my outfit. Trust me folks, you won’t regret adding this outfit set to your wardrobe! Cheers, James – an old soul from the roaring twenties.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

As someone who has attended numerous costume parties and events, I can confidently say that dressing up in a Great Gatsby-inspired outfit is an absolute must. The 1920s era, which the novel is set in, was a time of decadence and opulence, and the fashion of that era perfectly captures the essence of the story.

Firstly, wearing a Great Gatsby costume allows you to fully immerse yourself in the world of the novel. It transports you back in time and makes you feel like you are a part of Jay Gatsby’s extravagant parties. The lavish suits, flapper dresses, and sparkling accessories help bring the characters and their stories to life.

Moreover, these costumes are incredibly stylish and eye-catching. The men’s attire consists of well-tailored suits with sharp lines and bold colors, making them stand out in any crowd. On the other hand, women’s fashion during this era was all about glitz and glamor. The iconic flapper dresses with their intricate beading and fringe details are bound to turn heads at any party.

In addition to being visually appealing, Great Gatsby costumes also have cultural significance. The 1920s were a time of rebellion against traditional societal norms, especially when it came to fashion. Women started wearing

My Buying Guide on ‘Great Gatsby Guy Costumes’

As someone who loves all things vintage and stylish, I have always been a fan of dressing up in Great Gatsby inspired costumes. From the dapper suits to the flashy accessories, there is something about the 1920s fashion that exudes elegance and sophistication. If you’re planning to attend a Great Gatsby themed party or event, here is my buying guide on how to put together the perfect Gatsby guy costume.

1. Research and Understand the 1920s Fashion

The first step to creating an authentic Great Gatsby costume is to do some research on the fashion trends of the 1920s. This will give you a better understanding of the style and help you make informed decisions when purchasing your costume pieces. Look for inspiration from old photographs, movies, and fashion magazines from that era.

2. Choose Your Outfit: Suit or Tuxedo?

The typical Gatsby guy costume consists of a suit or a tuxedo. If you want to go for a more casual look, opt for a three-piece suit with pinstripes or solid colors like navy blue or gray. For a more formal and extravagant look, go for a tuxedo with tails in black or white.

3. Pay Attention to Details

In addition to the main outfit, it’s important to pay attention to smaller details like accessories that can enhance your costume’s authenticity. A pocket watch on a chain, suspenders, cufflinks, and fedora hats are all classic 1920s accessories that will add flair to your outfit.

4. Don’t Forget About Shoes

The right pair of shoes can make or break your Gatsby guy costume. Oxfords or wingtip dress shoes in black or brown are perfect choices for this era. Make sure they are polished and in good condition to complete your look.

5. Consider Renting Instead of Purchasing

If you don’t have all the necessary pieces for your Great Gatsby costume, consider renting them instead of buying everything new. This can save you money while still allowing you to achieve an authentic look.

6. Quality Over Quantity

When purchasing your costume pieces, it’s important to prioritize quality over quantity. Investing in well-made items will not only make your outfit look more authentic but also ensure that it lasts longer.

7. Have Fun with Accessories

The 1920s were all about accessorizing from headbands with feathers to long pearl necklaces; there are endless options when it comes to adding extra touches to your outfit. Don’t be afraid to have fun and experiment with different accessories until you find the perfect combination.

8. Try Thrift Stores and Vintage Shops

If you’re on a budget or looking for unique pieces, thrift stores and vintage shops are great places to find items for your Great Gatsby costume. You never know what treasures you may find at these stores that will add authenticity and character to your outfit.

In conclusion, creating an authentic Great Gatsby guy costume requires some research, attention to detail, and creativity with accessories. Remember not to stress too much about finding every single piece; as long as you have the main elements like a suit/tuxedo and appropriate shoes, everything else can be easily added on through accessories.
So put on your best 1920s attire and get ready for a night of glamour at any Great Gatsby themed event!

Author Profile

Avatar
Mary Barnhart
Welcome to Simply b, a creative realm where custom paper goods and invitations are more than just products—they are a personal experience tailored to each client. At the helm of this award-winning design studio is Mary Barnhart, a devoted artist residing in Newburyport with her family.

With her husband Jeff and their two children, Ellie and Henry, Mary cultivates a life filled with creativity, coastal beauty, and a passion for small businesses.

Since 2024, Mary has expanded her creative pursuits to include blogging, sharing her insights and expertise through informative posts that delve into personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This new venture is a seamless extension of her commitment to authenticity and quality, mirroring the ethos of Simply b’s "Simply b Yourself" Collection.

This collection not only features her exquisite stationery designs but also everyday items from collaborations with like-minded women entrepreneurs, encouraging women everywhere to embrace their unique selves.