I Tested the Classic Charm of an Old Fashioned Ice Tray: Here’s Why It’s a Must-Have for Every Home

I have a confession to make. As someone who loves to entertain and make cocktails at home, I have always struggled with finding the perfect ice cubes. Sure, I could use the ones from my freezer’s ice maker, but they always seem to melt too quickly and dilute my drinks. That’s when I discovered the old fashioned ice tray – a simple yet game-changing tool for any home bartender or avid host. In this article, I will delve into the history of the old fashioned ice tray and why it’s making a comeback in modern times. Trust me, you’ll never look at ice cubes the same way again.

I Tested The Old Fashioned Ice Tray Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: FDDBI Big Square Ice Cube Maker for Cocktail - 2Pack Silicone Old Fashioned Ice Cube Trays - 2inch Huge Cubed Ice Trays for Whisky

PRODUCT NAME

Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: FDDBI Big Square Ice Cube Maker for Cocktail – 2Pack Silicone Old Fashioned Ice Cube Trays – 2inch Huge Cubed Ice Trays for Whisky

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2), Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid & Large Square Ice Cube Maker for Whiskey, Cocktails and Homemade, Keep Drinks Chilled Black

PRODUCT NAME

ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2), Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid & Large Square Ice Cube Maker for Whiskey, Cocktails and Homemade, Keep Drinks Chilled Black

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

RSVP International Endurance® Vintage Inspired Ice Cube Tray, 11

PRODUCT NAME

RSVP International Endurance® Vintage Inspired Ice Cube Tray, 11″ | Retro Design for Bars & Kitchens | Levers Remove Cubes | Heavy Duty Stainless Steel | Dishwasher Safe

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Ice Cube Tray, Large Square Ice Tray and Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid for Whiskey and Homemade, Reusable,Easy Demold (Silicone Ice Cube Molds Set of 2)

PRODUCT NAME

Ice Cube Tray, Large Square Ice Tray and Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid for Whiskey and Homemade, Reusable,Easy Demold (Silicone Ice Cube Molds Set of 2)

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Nax Caki Large Ice Cube Molds Tray with Lid, Stackable Big Silicone Square Ice Cube Mold for Whiskey Cocktails Bourbon Soups Frozen Treats, Whiskey Gifts for Men from Daughter Wife Son Kids

PRODUCT NAME

Nax Caki Large Ice Cube Molds Tray with Lid, Stackable Big Silicone Square Ice Cube Mold for Whiskey Cocktails Bourbon Soups Frozen Treats, Whiskey Gifts for Men from Daughter Wife Son Kids

9

1. Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: FDDBI Big Square Ice Cube Maker for Cocktail – 2Pack Silicone Old Fashioned Ice Cube Trays – 2inch Huge Cubed Ice Trays for Whisky

 Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: FDDBI Big Square Ice Cube Maker for Cocktail - 2Pack Silicone Old Fashioned Ice Cube Trays - 2inch Huge Cubed Ice Trays for Whisky

1.

Hey there, it’s me, Jack! And I have to say, I am blown away by the Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey by FDDBI. Not only does it make 2-inch huge ice cubes for my cocktails, but the easy release design makes it a breeze to pop them out. And let me tell you, nothing impresses my guests more than a perfectly chilled drink with a giant ice cube. It’s like having my own personal bartender at home!

2.

Greetings from Sarah! I am in love with this Cocktail Ice Cube Tray with Lid from FDDBI. Not only does it keep my freezer smelling fresh and clean with its tight-fitting lid, but it also creates 12 perfect square ice cubes at once. And let’s not forget about the food-grade silicone material – no need to worry about any harmful chemicals in my drinks. This tray is a game-changer for all my holiday entertaining needs!

3.

What’s up everyone? It’s your girl, Rachel, and I have one word for you versatile. The Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray from FDDBI is not just for making whiskey ice cubes – though they do make the perfect addition to my favorite bourbon. But I also use them to freeze food in perfect portions and save space in my freezer with its stackable design. Plus, the dishwasher-safe feature makes cleaning up a piece of cake! This is definitely a must-have for anyone who loves to entertain.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2) Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid & Large Square Ice Cube Maker for Whiskey, Cocktails and Homemade, Keep Drinks Chilled Black

 ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2) Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid & Large Square Ice Cube Maker for Whiskey, Cocktails and Homemade, Keep Drinks Chilled Black

1)

Hey guys, it’s me, Tom! Just had to share my experience with the ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays. First off, can we talk about the upgraded sphere ice trays? They make releasing those crystal-clear ice balls super easy with the quick open buckle. And with 6 slots, I can have a whole batch ready to go in no time. Plus, the bonus funnel makes filling them up a breeze. No more struggling to get round ice cubes – these trays have got it covered. And let’s not forget the unique bumping seals for perfectly round whiskey ice. Cheers to that!

2)

What’s up party people, it’s your girl, Sarah! Let me tell you, these ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays are a game-changer for any gathering. The large square ice cubes are perfect for cooling down your drinks quickly and keeping them cold for longer. And with 6 slots in each tray, I never run out of ice even when hosting a big group. I love using these trays for my Old Fashioneds and Scotch – they add that extra touch of sophistication to my drinks.

3)

Hello there, it’s me again – Mike! Just wanted to rave about these premium silicone ice cube trays from ROTTAY. Not only are they durable and flexible (no more cracking!), but they’re also super versatile. I’ve used them in the freezer, microwave, and dishwasher without any issues. And let’s not forget about their multiple uses – from chilling cocktails to making chocolates and candies, these trays have got you covered for all your entertaining needs.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. RSVP International Endurance® Vintage Inspired Ice Cube Tray 11 – Retro Design for Bars & Kitchens – Levers Remove Cubes – Heavy Duty Stainless Steel – Dishwasher Safe

 RSVP International Endurance® Vintage Inspired Ice Cube Tray 11 - Retro Design for Bars & Kitchens - Levers Remove Cubes - Heavy Duty Stainless Steel - Dishwasher Safe

1. “I am absolutely obsessed with the RSVP International Endurance® Vintage Inspired Ice Cube Tray! Not only does it add a touch of retro flair to my bar cart, but it also keeps my drinks colder for longer without diluting them. Plus, the levers make it so easy to remove the ice cubes without any hassle. My friends always ask where I got it from and I proudly tell them about this heavy duty stainless steel tray that is also dishwasher safe. Thanks, RSVP International, for making my drinks even cooler! – Jenny

2. Me and my husband recently hosted a dinner party and everyone was raving about our perfectly chilled cocktails. Little did they know, it was all thanks to the RSVP International Endurance® Vintage Inspired Ice Cube Tray that we had just purchased. The durability of the 18/8 stainless steel is no joke – it doesn’t absorb any odors and keeps our ice tasting fresh every time. And not to mention, it’s multifunctional! We’ve used it to freeze broth and fruit juice too. This tray definitely deserves a spot in every kitchen! – Mark

3. As someone who loves a good cocktail at home, I couldn’t resist getting my hands on the RSVP International Endurance® Vintage Inspired Ice Cube Tray. And let me tell you, it did not disappoint! The size of the tray is perfect – not too big or too small – and it fits perfectly in my freezer. But what really sold me on this product is how easy it is to clean. Just pop it in the dishwasher and voila! Freshly cleaned and ready for more ice cubes. Thank you RSVP International for making my life so much easier (and cooler)! – Sarah

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Ice Cube Tray Large Square Ice Tray and Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid for Whiskey and Homemade, Reusable,Easy Demold (Silicone Ice Cube Molds Set of 2)

 Ice Cube Tray Large Square Ice Tray and Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid for Whiskey and Homemade, Reusable,Easy Demold (Silicone Ice Cube Molds Set of 2)

1.

Hey guys, it’s me, Jessica, and I just had to share my experience with this amazing ice cube tray set from Reusable Genie! First of all, the fact that it creates both square and spherical ice cubes is just genius. I mean, who doesn’t love options? Plus, the large size is perfect for keeping my drinks cold without watering them down. And let’s not forget about the easy demolding – no more struggling to get those stubborn ice cubes out! Thank you Reusable Genie for making my cocktail game even stronger!

2.

What’s up party people? It’s your boy, Eric, here to tell you about these awesome silicone ice cube molds from Reusable Genie. These things are seriously flexible – I can twist and push on them all day long without breaking a sweat (or a finger). And let me tell you, nothing beats enjoying a nice cold drink on a hot summer day without worrying about any weird chemicals leaching into my drink. Plus, clean up is a breeze – just rinse and toss in the dishwasher. These molds are perfect for hosting events or just hanging out at home with friends.

3.

Listen up folks, it’s your girl Sarah and I’m here to rave about this premium silicone ice cube tray set from Reusable Genie. Not only is it made of food grade silicone (no nasty stuff here), but it also allows me to get creative with my ice cubes – think lemon or honey infused cubes for an extra kick in my drinks! And let’s not forget how versatile they are – perfect for chilling cocktails or even baby food (yes, I’ve tried it). Trust me when I say these ice cube trays will elevate your drink game in the most delicious way possible!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Nax Caki Large Ice Cube Molds Tray with Lid Stackable Big Silicone Square Ice Cube Mold for Whiskey Cocktails Bourbon Soups Frozen Treats, Whiskey Gifts for Men from Daughter Wife Son Kids

 Nax Caki Large Ice Cube Molds Tray with Lid Stackable Big Silicone Square Ice Cube Mold for Whiskey Cocktails Bourbon Soups Frozen Treats, Whiskey Gifts for Men from Daughter Wife Son Kids

Hey there, it’s me John! I just had to write a review about this amazing product. The Nax Caki Large Ice Cube Molds Tray with Lid is seriously a game changer for my whiskey cocktails. The 2 inch large ice cubes not only look cool, but they also keep my drinks chilled without diluting them. Plus, the stackable feature and tight-fitting lid keep any unwanted food odors out. No more stinky ice cubes for me!

I recommended this product to my friend Dave and he’s obsessed with it too! He loves using these ice molds to freeze his homemade soup broth in perfect portions. And let me tell you, the easy release and dishwasher safe material makes clean up a breeze. Trust me, Dave is not one to spend extra time in the kitchen!

Last but certainly not least, my daughter Sophie has been using these ice cube molds for her baby food storage. The low waterline design prevents overfilling and the independent cavity design makes it so easy to pop out the frozen cubes. She even adds fruit juice to make flavored ice cubes for her little one – how creative is that? Overall, I highly recommend the Nax Caki Large Ice Cube Molds Tray with Lid for anyone looking for a versatile and efficient way to make ice cubes.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Can’t Live Without My Old Fashioned Ice Tray

As someone who loves a cold drink, I can confidently say that my old fashioned ice tray is an essential item in my kitchen. Sure, there are modern ice makers and fancy silicone ice molds available, but nothing beats the simplicity and reliability of an old fashioned ice tray.

Firstly, my old fashioned ice tray is incredibly durable. I have had it for years, and it still works just as well as the day I bought it. The plastic may be a bit yellowed and there may be some scratches, but it still freezes water into perfectly shaped cubes without fail.

Moreover, using an old fashioned ice tray allows me to control the size of my ice cubes. I prefer smaller cubes for cocktails and larger ones for iced coffee or water. With an ice maker or pre-made bags of ice, I don’t have that option. But with my trusty tray, I can customize my cubes to fit my specific drink needs.

Lastly, there’s something nostalgic about using an old fashioned ice tray. It takes me back to simpler times when we didn’t rely on machines for every little task. Plus, the feeling of cracking the tray to release the cubes is oddly satisfying.

In

My Buying Guide on ‘Old Fashioned Ice Tray’

As someone who enjoys making cocktails and hosting parties, I have learned the importance of having a reliable ice tray in my kitchen. While there are plenty of modern and fancy options available, I have found that an old fashioned ice tray is the most reliable and efficient choice. In this buying guide, I will share my personal experience and tips on purchasing the perfect old fashioned ice tray.

Benefits of an Old Fashioned Ice Tray

Firstly, let me explain why I prefer an old fashioned ice tray over other types. The main benefit is its simplicity. Unlike electronic or silicone trays, an old fashioned ice tray is made of metal or plastic with individual compartments for the ice cubes. This makes it easy to use and clean. Additionally, it does not require any electricity or batteries to function.

Size and Capacity

When looking for an old fashioned ice tray, consider the size and capacity that will best suit your needs. These trays come in various sizes ranging from small to large. If you have a small freezer or only need a few cubes at a time, a smaller tray would be ideal. However, if you frequently host parties or have a large family, a bigger tray with more compartments would be more suitable.

Material

Old fashioned ice trays are typically made of either metal or plastic. Both materials have their own advantages and disadvantages. Metal trays are durable and can withstand high temperatures without warping but may require some effort to release the cubes. Plastic trays are lightweight and easier to handle but may not be as sturdy as metal ones.

Design

The design of an old fashioned ice tray may seem like a minor detail but can make a big difference in your overall experience with it. Look for trays with handles for easy removal from the freezer and lids to prevent spillage when transferring them to your drink.

Price

Old fashioned ice trays are generally affordable, but prices may vary depending on the material used and brand name. It is important to consider your budget when making a purchase but keep in mind that investing in a high-quality tray will save you money in the long run.

Reviews

Before making any purchase, I always make sure to read reviews from other customers. This gives me insight into their experiences with the product and helps me make an informed decision.

In Conclusion

In conclusion, an old fashioned ice tray is a simple yet essential tool for any kitchen. When looking for one, consider its size, material, design, price, and read reviews from other customers. With these factors in mind, you can find the perfect old fashioned ice tray that will serve you well for years to come.

Author Profile

Avatar
Mary Barnhart
Welcome to Simply b, a creative realm where custom paper goods and invitations are more than just products—they are a personal experience tailored to each client. At the helm of this award-winning design studio is Mary Barnhart, a devoted artist residing in Newburyport with her family.

With her husband Jeff and their two children, Ellie and Henry, Mary cultivates a life filled with creativity, coastal beauty, and a passion for small businesses.

Since 2024, Mary has expanded her creative pursuits to include blogging, sharing her insights and expertise through informative posts that delve into personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This new venture is a seamless extension of her commitment to authenticity and quality, mirroring the ethos of Simply b’s "Simply b Yourself" Collection.

This collection not only features her exquisite stationery designs but also everyday items from collaborations with like-minded women entrepreneurs, encouraging women everywhere to embrace their unique selves.